It’s no secret that the world of beard grooming products is confusing.
You’ve just learned about beard oils and picked your favorite one and now you’re hearing you also need a beard balm and butter if you want your beard to be top-notch the whole day.
Like a good beardsman you are, you want to offer your facial hair only the best of the best.
So, you start searching which is a better option for you.
Everything you find online indicated that both butter and balm are fairly similar, which doesn’t help at all.
If you feel confused and unsure, don’t sweat.
Most men need embarrassingly long time to find which between these two products they should get and what are the nuanced, little differences that separate them.
To shorten your learning curve, in this guide we compare beard balm and beard butter key differences to help you make an informed decision and pick the best one for your mane.
Table Of Contents
- 3 Top Picks Of Beard Butter
- 3 Top Picks Of Beard Balm
- 2. Viking Revolution
- 3. Rocky Mountain Barber Company
- What Is a Beard Balm
- Benefits of Using a Beard Balm
- How Does a Beard Balm Work
- Pros and Cons of Beard Balms
- How to Use Beard Balm
- What Is Beard Butter
- Benefits of Using Beard Butter
- How Does Beard Butter Work
- Pros and Cons of a Beard Butter
- How to Use a Beard Butter
- Beard Balm vs Beard Butter Comparison
- Does More Spending Mean More Quality
- Dos and Don’ts
3 Top Picks Of Beard Butter
Live Bearded was launched in 2016 by two best friends who understood their fellow beardmen’s need to feel, look, and be at their best while sporting their beards. They believe that if you look and feel good, you’ll perform better in other aspects of your life. All their products are created not only for the suit-and-tie-wearing beardmen but for any bearded fellow who wants to take control of their lives.
You can choose from its cedar, vanilla, and leather scent profiles. It’s made from all-natural ingredients like grapeseed, almond, avocado, and coconut, responsible for the medium and light hold. With these non-heavy and non-toxic ingredients, you can surely keep your beard alive and healthy minus the greasy feel. These ingredients don’t only moisturize, but they also keep your beard hard and skin looking genuinely good.
If you’re conscious about your beard and you’re looking for a complete beard growth kit, you can use Live Bearded’s boar’s hairbrush, beard oil, and beard wash that all mesh well with their beard butter. With all these products at your disposal, you will surely grow your beard to its full potential.
The even better news is that the company offers a full refund when customers are unsatisfied with their purchase. They stand by the efficacy and potency of their product that they also provide a lifetime guarantee. So, anytime you want an exchange or refund, just let them know.
- All-natural ingredients
- Non-greasy finish
- Light hold
- Manly, fresh scent profiles
- Smell could be offensive or off-putting for some
The company updated its beard butter formula to match the original formula to answer their customers’ pleas. Now, they’ve been exceeding everyone’s expectations with these new fragrances and natural ingredients. Their unique moisturizer could transform your dry and unruly beard while also relieving you with itchiness. All you get is a great-looking beard with a light, clean, and fresh smell.
They use their exclusive natural formula made of mango and shea butter mixed with coconut oil. All these can tame your beard, minus the greasy feel. The cream also applies evenly and absorbs naturally. In the end, you get a soft and natural-looking beard that always smells great. Since the cream is light, it won’t leave you feeling sticky or tacky.
This formula is also great for itchy and dry skin. The company has been listening to its clientele, and because of that, they have constantly been improving their formulation. Now, their new formula keeps the flaking down to a bare minimum. Without the flaking and itchy feeling, you can be more confident and comfortable.
Their formulation also has a perfect consistency and lightweight texture for beards. It softens, balances, and conditions the beard by spreading throughout with no problem. They’re also serious about their claim to make their customers 100% satisfied. With this, if you’re not satisfied with their product, you can expect them to offer a full refund cheerfully, no questions asked.
- Fresh and clean smelling
- Unique formula made of coconut oil, shea butter, and mango butter
- Non-sticky formula that leaves the skin and hair non-greasy
- Good for skin flaking and itching
- Less strong hold compared to the original formula
- Stronger scent
If you’re looking for a formula that could deal effectively with an unruly and itchy beard, then Maestro’s Classic beard butter should be your go-to product. It’s especially uniquely formulated to groom and hydrate. This beard butter is also a hydrating cream that’s oil-based and water-soluble. They bring moisture to your face and skin without the greasy, tacky feel.
The resulting reaction of this unique formula is a less itchy beard and an instant soothing sensation. It’s a lightweight cream that’s filled with conditioning agents best for managing and softening beards. Feedback and reviews from satisfied customers reveal that the product is undeniably good in laying down their beards every single time.
This cream is formulated with bergamot, black pepper, and grapefruit notes for a classy, executive-like feeling, scent, and experience. You can say that the product is 100% safe and free from toxins with all these natural ingredients. You can apply a generous amount regularly without fear of the product being wrong on the skin.
The safety data sheet provided by the company’s production facility also claimed that the formula has a PH level of 5.3 to 6.3. This soluble, water-based formula is safe for different skin types. Its consistency is best as an overnight cream.
- Oil-based and water-soluble
- Natural oils and butter as ingredients
- Best for itching and flaking skin
- Nice smell
- Users think that the runny consistency does little for their skin
3 Top Picks Of Beard Balm
This beard balm comes in three scents – cedar, anise, and clove. Regardless of the smell, this product is made with only the finest organic ingredients. The markers started with a proprietary mixture of natural hair strengthening botanical products infused with apricot kernel, pumpkin seed, avocado, almond, and argan oils.
Afterwhich, they were carefully crafted with nut and fruit butter like Kokum, Cocoa, Aloe, and Shea. Apart from that, essential oils with hair-enhancing capabilities were also added to strengthen the formula. They also chose subtle scents of clove, licorice (anise), and cedarwood not to put off those with a keen sense of smell. The makers suggest any user with nut allergies test the product first before applying generously or avoid it altogether.
This balm promises to nourish new hair growth and condition and soften dry, splitting hair. This balm is excellent for stopping the itch related to the growth of wild and new rogue hair. However, note that the balm is only made with natural ingredients; the product may separate when exposed to changing temperatures.
Still, the balm will work as usual, except that you have to manipulate it when you melt them in your hand. To return to its normal consistency, place the balm in a warm place. As soon as it melts, shake the closed bottle or canister and mix it up.
- Made with all-natural and non-synthetic products
- Rich with vitamins and minerals
- The company offers a 100% full refund policy
- It needs to be warmed up when exposed to fluctuating temperature
This deeply nourishing and natural waxy balm is essential to every bearded man’s regular maintenance and grooming routine. This is a non-greasy styling balm that is easy and fast to apply. You don’t need to rinse your beard after using it. After applying, you will notice your beard quickly straighten and soften. You’ll also see it work seamlessly with frizzy and wild stray hair. Your mustache and beard will indeed feel under control and smooth.
This moisturizing balm works its way down to the roots of every hair follicle, nourishing and moisturizing the skin to steer clear of beard dandruff and flaking. You will surely relieve yourself of that annoying beard itch. Plus, you won’t have to worry about the residue. This product is packed with essential oils like beeswax, mango butter, Jojoba Oil, and Argan oil. They also finished the formula off with a clean, crisp, citrusy smell that will leave you feeling fresh all day.
The people behind this phenomenal product are bearded men seeking to find the perfect product to help their fellow bearded men grow their beards confidently. Because this product is personal to them, they ensured that it would be safe, non-toxic, cruelty and allergen-free, and 100% natural. You can confidently use it without worrying about adverse side effects.
The makers made sure that the beard balm comes in man-size quantities to ensure that any bearded man won’t run out of balms before they can get one. They also carefully curated the scent to make it masculine yet fresh.
- Made with all-natural and non-synthetic products
- Rich with vitamins and minerals
- The company offers a 100% full refund policy
- The hold could be less intense than preferred
One of the main selling points of this balm is its ability to alleviate itchiness. This balm has been specially formulated to ensure that your beard and skin get all the nourishment, vitamins, and minerals they need to keep feeling and looking healthy. If you’re having issues with skin flaking and beard dandruff, this is best for you.
It has a cedarwood scent and features Jojoba Oil, shea butter, beeswax, and grapeseed oil. All of these are meant to protect your beard. Cedarwood, in particular, encourages hair growth while reducing hair loss. It also has antibacterial and anti-fungal properties that treat all conditions that lead to dandruff.
It also helps shine and add shape to one’s beard while promoting a full-looking and healthy beard. The products have been crafted in smaller batches to assure the buyers that every product exhibits superb quality and maximum freshness.
The makers of this product take their reputation and product quality to heart. This explains why they are confident with the quality and effectiveness of their product. For best results, the makers suggest using the balm with the Rocky Mountain Beard brush or comb.
- Made with all the finest, natural ingredients
- Made with cedarwood
- Promotes a healthy and full-looking beard
- The smell could be off-putting or offensive to certain users
What Is a Beard Balm
A beard balm is a commonly used beard care product with beeswax, shea butter, essential oils, and carrier oils.
A well-maintained beard is attractive. A beard balm will condition your beard and keep it healthy while also giving it the hold it needs for you to shape it as you desire. The beeswax in a beard balm will help you style your beard and help you retain moisture in it.
Benefits of Using a Beard Balm
Prevents Beard Dandruff
A beard balm helps to prevent dandruff in your beard. The beeswax in a beard balm helps your beard retain moisture and reduce flaking of the skin. Skin flakes are usually the biggest source of dandruff on your beard.
A good beard balm will help you avoid an itchy beard, especially during the first 2-4 weeks of growing a beard. The beeswax is again at play as it helps to seal in both beard oil and natural oils in your beard and reduce the itchiness caused by budding beard hairs and dryness. The beard wax gives you ultimate control over your beard, allowing you to style and shape it as you wish.
Protection Against the Elements
A beard balm will also help to protect your beard from the elements such as harsh weather and sunshine. The carrier oils in a balm will help keep your skin nourished, while the beeswax will help create a thin protective layer for your beard. A beard balm can make your hair look full when it holds your beard together.
How Does a Beard Balm Work
A beard balm works by giving a protective layer to your beard while also locking in the moisture to keep your beard and the skin underneath hydrated. The ingredients in a good beard balm will complement each other and protect your beard from elements while also keeping it healthy and well-groomed.
A beard balm will also help you style your beard and hold the style in place for the rest of the day. You can achieve painless detangling by using a beard relaxer. Get one of the world’s best aftershave balm to use on your beard.
Pros and Cons of Beard Balms
- A good beard balm will keep your beard looking healthy by reducing dandruff, dead ends, and split ends through its natural ingredients
- A beard balm will help you style your beard with beeswax, which is an ingredient. Beeswax will help lay down unruly beard hair and help your brush or comb glide through your beard hair. You will be assured of a painless beard hair growth journey
- A beard balm will help you get a smooth and conditioned beard, easy and painless to maintain
- Beard balms are only right for long beards because of the beeswax, making the beard according to style
- You need to be careful when using a beard balm because too much of it may not be absorbed by your beard. You might end up having the flakes you were avoiding in the first place
How to Use Beard Balm
A beard balm is a solution to all your beard needs. You could use a homemade beard balm or buy one from the market. If you are struggling with a dry, brittle, and thin beard, then you need to scout the market for a good beard balm. Here is how to use your beard balm.
Step 1 – Wash your beard
Use quality beard soap or shampoo to clean your beard to remove any dirt or particles in it. You never know what could be hidden in your beard!
Step 2 – Dry your beard
You do not apply beard balm to a wet beard. Wait for your beard to dry and then start applying the balm.
Step 3 – Apply the beard balm
Scoop some beard balm from the container and rub it in between your palms. Run your fingers from the neck to the chin, making sure that the skin gets some of that balm.
Repeat the same process, now starting from the chin down to your neck. Run your fingers through your cheeks if you have a beard there. Now, use a beard comb or brush to style your beard.
Repeat this process daily for the best results.
What Is Beard Butter
Beard butter is a combination of beard oil and balm, which will help you achieve the results you want with your beard. Beard butter will give your beard a smoother feel and help seal moisture in your beard while keeping it healthy and well-groomed. It can also give your beard a great scent if you choose butter with a great essential oil as a component.
Beard butter has all the essential ingredients of beard oil, wax, and balm, making it one of the best products to have.
Benefits of Using Beard Butter
Beard butter is a combination of both beard balm and beard oil. This means that you might not need to buy another oil and balm to tend to your beard. The beard growth oil helps improve your beard’s growth, while the balm helps you shape your beard. This is a money-saving product, and it reduces your hassle of looking for a balm and oil that work well together.
Locks in Moisture
Beard butter also helps you seal in moisture in your beard while treating your skin to reduce the chances of flaking and forming dandruff. It works for both the facial hair and the skin underneath, giving you a great experience all day long.
How Does Beard Butter Work
A beard butter works to keep your beard healthy and well-groomed by treating both the hair and the skin underneath. Beard butter usually consists of essential oils which give your beard a great scent and has carrier oils that help in beard growth.
Beard butter also has beeswax as an ingredient that helps you style your beard and hold it all day long. If you get yourself a good beard butter, you might as well say goodbye to bad beard days.
Pros and Cons of a Beard Butter
- Beard butter will keep your beard well-conditioned and moisturized, making it easier to handle and painless to brush
- Beard butter carries both the qualities of beard oil and beard balm, making it a one-stop-shop for all your beard needs
- A good beard bitter will enhance the growth of your beard and keep it well-groomed
- Beard butter is solid and might be hard to get absorbed into your beard and skin. You may need to rub it thoroughly so that it gets assimilated into your beard
- You need to be sure that the beard butter you use on your beard is of high quality. If not, you may end up with unmelted flakes on your beard, which can be very unsightly
How to Use a Beard Butter
Step 1 – Clean your beard
Make sure that your beard is clean and dry before you apply your butter. If you apply beard butter on a wet beard, you are less likely to get it seeped in.
Step 2 – Rub it on your palms
Scoop a sufficient amount of the butter with your finger and rub it on your palms. Apply it evenly on your beard, starting with the chin area and then the cheek area.
Step 3 – Comb and style your beard
Comb or brush your beard to your desired style and rock your beard all day long. You can trim and shape your beard with premium hair-cutting shears and remember, a tapered beard goes with any face shape.
Beard Balm vs Beard Butter Comparison
Both beard balms and butter are excellent products to tend to your beard. The best product depends on the type of your beard and its length.
If your beard is smaller and younger, you will find beard butter as the most appropriate product. However, if your beard is older and longer, then beard balm would be the most appropriate product.
The beard balm vs beard butter debate will go on as long as people continue to grow beards. Get the product that works best for you.
Does More Spending Mean More Quality
The price of a product does not always measure its quality. Read the ingredients of a product and what it will do to decide whether it is worth the price tag.
Dos and Don’ts
- Do buy the most appropriate product for your beard
- Do your research on what each product offers you
- Do clean your beard before applying butter or balm
- Don’t apply either butter or balm on a wet beard
Can you use beard butter and beard balm together?
No. Use only one of the products at a time, depending on your beard’s needs.
Should I use beard balm every day?
If you wash your beard every day, then yes, you can use a beard balm every day.
Should I use beard butter at night?
No. The best time to use beard butter is during the day when your beard is most exposed.
Do you leave beard butter in?
Beard butter also serves as a leave-in conditioner for your beard. However, it is advisable to clean it off before you sleep to allow your skin pores to exfoliate.
When should you start using beard balm?
Start using beard balm when your beard is longer and you need help shaping it and holding it in position.
The beard butter vs beard balm debate has been on for many decades and will continue for as long as the two products remain in the market. The products have unique benefits for your beard and you cannot pick one over the other. Understand the needs of your beard before you pick any of the two products.
Photos from: indrepau / depositphotos.com,