Best Shaving Soap for a Luxury Lather

When it comes to men’s products, shaving soap has been around for just about as long as the concept of shaving itself.

These days, canned shaving cream has mostly taken its place on convenience store shelves.

However, those who value tradition, quality and luxury still suds up with a quality puck when it’s time to trim their whiskers.

Though it requires a bit more time and effort, these products are perfect for men who value class, grandeur, and the timelessness of quality shave.

Shaving Soap Benefits

Unlike shaving cream or gel, shaving soap comes in a hard puck. It takes a little bit of skill and preparation to use and has thus become less popular than other, instant shaving alternatives.

Shaving Soap Benefits

Sure, they take a little bit more time to prepare for use than quick and easy foam methods, but Rome wasn’t built in a day; a quality shave is well worth the time it takes for a soap puck to soak and soften.

Closer Shave

Shaving soap’s delicate consistency allows for a bit more precision than products like canned shaving cream.

By providing additional cushion and slickness, it allows the blade to sever hairs closer to the skin without leaving behind pesky nicks or cuts.

This allows for an overall closer shave without any danger of infection or razor burn.


Speaking generally, shaving soap usually has higher-quality ingredients that allow for heightened performance.

Because products like shaving cream must include additional preservatives and accelerants in order to permit canned storage, their overall quality is inevitably lesser.

Shaving soaps, on the other hand, generally have straightforward, natural ingredients list. For those who are truly invested in the quality of their shave, there’s no better option.


Because the best shaving soaps can be used with any type of razor from safety razors to straight razor and shavettes, it’s noted for its versatility.

It also improves the shaving experience of men with all hair types from thick to thin and everything in between (except maybe of course a back shaver).


If this is your first go-round with the purchase of a high-quality shaving soap, your head might be spinning at labels that drop terms like “triple-milled,” or “croap”.

Before you run out and sink your money into a shaving soap, you’ll want to learn a little of the lingo.

The three major types of shaving soaps are as follows:


Most of the shaving soaps on the market are triple-milled. This means they’ve been grated and processed in order to be a bit more user-friendly.

Their only downfall is that they do tend to be costlier than their semi-hard or croap competitors. However, their harder pucks mean they last longer and (in some cases) are well worth the higher price.

If you’re here, it probably means you value the shaving experience. No wet shave is a cheap shave.

If you want to feel like you’ve just gotten out of one of those classic chairs for the barber shop in some old-school professional’s store, then you’re after quality. When it comes to quality, cost makes all the difference.


Semi-hard soap products fall somewhere in the middle of the line between hard triple-milled products and softer croaps.

Their goal is to serve as the perfect compromise between triple-milled and croaps: they have most of the benefits of the former, with the softness of the former.

However, because they haven’t been grated and re-processed like their triple-milled competitors, they’re life is a bit shorter.


Okay, so it sounds a little like a noise a bullfrog would make. We promise it has nothing to do with amphibians. In fact, “croap” refers to products which are soap-cream hybrids.

Because of the manufacturing process used to produce these types, they also carry more moisture, which makes them softer and a bit easier to use.

Croap and softer soaps and convenient, as they don’t require a shaving brush to lather.

Animal Tallow vs Vegetable

Tallow, which is an animal fat product, is a common, traditional ingredient in shaving soaps. For a traditional barbershop shave, tallow products are the go-to, old-school option.

However, if you’re (understandably) a bit put off by the idea of rubbing animal fat on your face, you do have other options.

Alternatively, modern products might include an oil (such as olive oil, coconut oil, palm oil or argan oil) as a tallow substitute. These serve the same function as tallow products, but with none of the animal by-products.

Outside of animal tallow and vegetable oil products, these days there’s also glycerin-based soaps.

These soaps are the new kids on the block and are generally a bit gentler than their tallow and oil competitors.

Shaving Soap For Sensitive Skin

While animal tallow is the classic option, those with sensitive skin should probably stick to glycerin-based shaving soaps.

Because they’re a bit gentler, they’re also less likely to irritate skin or cause itching and outbreaks.

However, if you’re using a glycerin-based soap and your skin is still dry or irritated, you may want to investigate the other products used in your shaving routine.

Try using a gentler aftershave or investing in the best face wash for sensitive skin.

Alternatively, if it isn’t your shaving products which are provoking your skin’s sensitivity, it might be the razor itself.

If you’re using a multi-blade razor, consider purchasing one of these best razors for sensitive skin or switching to a single-blade safety razor.

Because safety razor blades cut facial hair at a less aggressive angle, they’re sometimes more agreeable to delicate skin.

Shaving Soap For Dry Skin

When it comes to combating dry skin, the key is in the lather. If a soap’s lather functions properly, it should condition the skin while still retaining its natural oils.

Additionally, you’ll want to seek out soaps which contain some kind of organic butter such as shea or mango.

What’s most important isn’t the shaving cream or gel, but what happens pre and post shave.

If you live in a climate with particularly dry or cold weather, you’ll want to be moisturizing daily regardless.

Consider kicking off your shaving routine with a moisturizing face wash and finishing it with a high-quality moisturizer.

Shaving Soap Alternatives

If shaving soap isn’t up your alley, you do have a couple other options.

Though they may not be as luxurious or timeless as a traditional shave with a puck and bowl, they do have their own pros. Here’s how the competition measures up.

Shaving Cream vs Shaving Soap

Shaving Cream vs Shaving Soap

If a high-quality shaving soap is a gourmet dish of spaghetti bolognaise prepared in Italy, then shaving cream is two-minute noodles.

The honest truth is that if you’re hungry, they’re both going to get the job done. That doesn’t mean one isn’t undeniably better than the other.

Shaving cream’s major advantage is that it’s so fast and easy to use. Because it usually comes in a quick-applicating container, it foams immediately and is ready for action as soon as it comes out.

There’s no preparation, thought or drama.

If you don’t have the time for shaving soap, but you love the warmth of a good lather, you can always purchase one of these top lather warmers as a middle-of-the-line compromise.

Shaving Gel vs Shaving Cream

When it comes down to it, shaving gels and shaving creams have pretty much the same ingredients.

However, saying that they’re the same thing would be a lot like saying mozzarella cheese and ice cream are the same thing because they both are sourced from dairy.

Gel differs from shaving cream mostly in the mere fact that it is gel. Because the consistency is different, it also has differing characteristics and performance.

Compared to cream and even soap, gel is much slicker. This makes it better at lubricating, but not without a cost: because gels are thicker, they’re also much more likely to clog your razor and slow the shaving process.

Choosing The Best Shaving Soap

So, you’ve sold yourself on purchasing a shaving soap. The next step is to pick a puck that’s going to suit your needs.

Because there’s so much variation on the market, this can be a bit of a slippery task. Don’t worry though, we’ve got your back.

Choosing The Best Shaving Soap


What draws most men to shaving soap is its texture, so it’s no wonder that the product’s overall feel is a major selling point.

When it comes to texture, cushioning and slickness are the two biggest factors.

Slickness is what reduces friction when shaving and ultimately prevents irritation or razor burn.

The slicker your soak is, the smoother your shave will be. If you’re after a classic close shave, you’ll want a slick soap that allows your razor to glide across your skin without resistance.

If the mention of “cushioning” has you thinking of couch cushions, you’re not exactly wrong.

Cushioning refers to a soap’s ability to act as a buffer between the razor and the skin. Sure, you want a close shave, but you don’t want the razor blade to actually make contact with your skin and cause damage.

Using a soap that has an effective cushion is a good way to help reduce razor burn, nicks and cuts.

However, if you do happen to have an “oopsie” and end up with a tiny injury, quickly enlist the help of a styptic pencil or some alum blocks to make sure no infection occurs.


Alright, “latherability” may not technically be a word endorsed officially by the Oxford English Dictionary, but you know exactly what it means.

If you’re like any other man who watched his father shave and envied his rich, creamy lather, you’re probably after a product that foams up pleasingly but also doesn’t take much to rinse.

Ideally, a lather will hit that perfect balance between thick, and light enough to wash.

However, if you’ve purchased a product which is supposed to lather well and it refuses to, you might want to check the water in your area.


A good shaving soap should leave a clean, pleasant smell behind in its path. Ideally, you want a soap with a fragrance that isn’t overpowering.

Commonly, fragranced soaps include citrusy hints or musky, masculine tinges. Regardless, a shaving soap’s smell should be light at best.

Ultimately, you should be turning to a good cologne or one of these best aftershaves for your fragrance.


An effective shaving soap won’t leave your skin dry, itchy or scaly. In contrast, it’ll leave your chin and cheeks feeling smooth and moisturized.

Because the skin on your face is easily dried out, it’s important to use products which seek to hydrate it; your shaving soap should be no different.

Again, products which contain shea butter or natural oils are often great at delivering moisture without stripping your skin’s natural balance.

Ease of Use

Ease of Use

A quality, professional-level shave can take as little or as much time as you have. For perfection-seeking shave enthusiasts, the whole process can take an hour or more.

Unfortunately, not everyone has that much time to spend on their morning shave. Which soap you select will also be determined, partially, on how much time and effort you’re willing to invest.

Harder soaps will take longer to soften for use, while croaps are generally ready more quickly.

If you’re pressed for time completely, you might consider skipping a shaving soap altogether in favor of a less-luxurious but more convenient canned cream.


Though there’s plenty of variation on the shaving soap market, they all generally have a couple ingredients in common. Most all soaps have the core ingredient of either tallow, oil, or glycerin.

Healthy Ingredients

Shea butter

Shea butter along with mango butter or other similar ingredients are great natural moisturizers which help ensure that you get a clean, smooth shave every time.

They also leave your skin feeling hydrated and renewed.


Made naturally from sheep’s wool, in recent years lanolin has become a staple ingredient in many high-quality skin products.

It’s a great stand-in for synthetic oil, which sometimes carries harmful toxins.

Natural oils

Natural oils such as avocado oil are great natural moisturizers. They also work to combat acne and give your skin an overall even, smooth appearance.

Bad Ingredients To Avoid

Synthetic preservatives

You never know what consequences these bad boys come with.

While products with synthetic preservatives might be less expensive and a little bit tempting, do your best to look the other way; they’re just not worth the risk.

Mineral Oil

Although the words “mineral oil” probably have positive, healthy connotations in your mind, when mixed into a shave soap it strips away your natural oils.

Sodium lauryl sulfate

Along with mineral oils, sodium lauryl sulfate is a culprit in the disappearance of the natural oils your body produces to regulate your skin’s hydration and overall health.

How To Use and Apply Shaving Soap

To get a barber-shop, professional cut and feel using shaving soap, you’ll need a shave brush, a shaving bowl, and a little bit of patience.

While it is possible to nix the shaving bowl and apply shaving soap onto your face, it’s not nearly as effective.

We’re guessing if you’re here it’s because you’re after a classic, quality shave, so we’ll cut right to the chase and give you the step-by-step directions on shaving with a bowl.

Step 1 – Preparation

Before you bust out your razor and get down to business, you’ll need to create an excellent lather. One of the key components of an A-grade shave with soap is the lather’s temperature.

Fill your shave bowl with hot water and also splash a bit of hot water onto your soap puck. Then, soak your shaving brush for a couple of minutes.

Step 2 – Create the Lather

Next, empty the bowl, leaving about a teaspoon of liquid at the bottom.

When the soap is softened, you’ll want to lightly whisk your wet brush across the bar’s surface.

Ideally, this will cause a thick, creamy lather. The perfect lather will be a velvety, whipped texture rather than thin or bubbly.

Step 3 – Apply

When your lather has reached the desired thickness and texture, you’re ready to start applying it.

Using a circular motion, lightly apply the soap with brisk, continuous brush strokes. Then, use your standard method for a clean, close shave.



You’re a classy man and you deserve a shave that matches your caliber.

Though canned creams offer immediate convenience, nothing quite has the look, feel and finish of traditional shaving soap.

For those who have the desire for a classic, clean shave, shaving soap is the only way to go.

If you’ve never tried it, you probably should. Your grandfather would be proud.

Articles you may also like:

Photos from: nejron /, [email protected] /, londondeposit /, iakovenko123 /, 

Pin It on Pinterest